This article is part of Witness: The Human Impact of Immigration Enforcement, an ongoing documentary project documenting the lives of people affected by immigration enforcement. My goal is to move beyond politics and headlines and help readers better understand the human stories often missing from the conversation.
Read more about the project and how you can participate.
For Cem Erdem, America offered the chance to build a life, a company, and opportunities for others. Thirty-two years later, he worries about what the country is giving away.
The Greatest Country to Build a Dream
On October 31, 1994—one day after marrying Elizabeth—Cem Erdem walked into the Minnesota Secretary of State’s office in St. Paul, filed a one-page form, and started a company.
The clerk went to the back, returned, and congratulated him. He was now the CEO of his own business.
Cem went outside and sat on the granite steps, looking toward downtown St. Paul. He was 26, newly arrived from Istanbul, and astonished.
In Turkey, he told me, starting a business could take months. You needed to know the right people. Here, he had filled out a piece of paper.
“This has to be the greatest country to build a dream. And if I can’t build it here, where else can I do it?”
He had almost no American business connections, and his English was limited. He didn’t yet know whether the company would survive. But he understood what had just happened: someone had opened a door, and the rules seemed to make sense.
Thirty-two years later, Cem is a successful entrepreneur who sold the company he founded. He is also a man who speaks about the country he remembers with unmistakable affection—and growing concern.
“It’s not the same place,” he told me.
From Istanbul to Minnesota — and Everything in Between
Cem hadn’t come to America with a grand plan to make his fortune. He came because he fell in love.
In the summer of 1993, he was island-hopping in Greece on a motorcycle when he met Elizabeth, a woman from Minnesota. They spent a week together and decided to marry. He sold what he owned, quit his job, and flew to a state he’d never heard of.

His impression of America came largely from television: Dallas, The Six Million Dollar Man, and Baywatch. Humorously, he was disappointed to discover that the beaches of Minnesota, or anywhere, looked nothing like the ones on television.
He arrived with $14,000—his life savings—hidden in his underwear. He wasn’t destitute. He had a university education and had been doing well in Turkey. But none of that gave him an established life in Minnesota.
On the flight from Istanbul, he read about a new technology called the Internet. Convinced it would change how people lived and worked, he began looking for a job at an Internet company. He couldn’t find one. Elizabeth suggested he start his own.
He did. That was the easy part.
The harder part was explaining the Internet to people who had never heard of it. When he called potential customers to ask whether they were on the Internet, some replied that they were downtown.
While trying to make his business work, he handled packages at UPS. One winter day, frustrated and needing money, he started shoveling strangers’ sidewalks and leaving notes asking for payment. Ten sidewalks earned him $120 from one elderly couple. It was, he admitted, not a particularly good business model.
And there was the language.
“When you lose your language, you lose your personality.”
In Turkey, Cem had been the fast-talking jokester, the person at the center of a gathering. Here, he didn’t understand the Seinfeld references or know how to respond quickly enough to join the joke. He grew quiet. Reserved. He had to learn how to be himself again.
That part of his story is hardly unique. Different reasons bring people to America—love, work, safety, a future for their children—but the unfamiliar language, the loss of community, the need to start again are common threads. Cem had drive and an education. He also had help.
Elizabeth read his emails, guided him through unfamiliar systems, and helped with his immigration paperwork. Later, a professor at the University of St. Thomas agreed to meet Cem every two weeks at a Starbucks. For nearly two years, he taught him how to run a business. Years afterward, when Cem tried to repay him with a large check, the professor refused.
“Pay it forward,” he said.
One Opportunity Becomes Hundreds
Cem did.
The company he started became Augusoft, a technology business whose software helped colleges and universities manage continuing-education enrollment. He built it over nearly three decades before selling it to Modern Campus in 2022.1
But the real measure of what happened is larger than a sale or a balance sheet.
Cem employed hundreds of people over the life of the company. He mentored entrepreneurs and invested in startups. He worked with Big Brothers Big Sisters and contributed money from the sale of his business to help start a school. The help he received didn’t end with him.
He was direct about this when we spoke. Even if he hadn’t done any of that charitable work, he said, his company had already employed people and paid taxes. Those contributions mattered. Then he added something just as important:
“I am very well aware of my privilege.”
He knows he worked hard. He also knows the environment helped him, and that his success was not inevitable.
Consider two people he hired. One was a programmer from Kenya who had earned a master’s degree at the University of St. Thomas. Cem sponsored him for an H-1B visa. The employee became so central to the company that, when a consultant asked the staff to name someone who embodied its values, they chose him. Another programmer, initially working with Augusoft from India, moved to the United States with the company’s sponsorship. He later became a citizen and built a life here.
These weren’t abstract “foreign workers” to Cem. They were people he knew. People whose abilities helped make his company better.
One immigrant’s opportunity can turn into other people’s paychecks, careers, businesses, and families. There is no guarantee that every newcomer will start a company. Nor should there be. A person doesn’t need to become rich to deserve dignity.
But what we risk losing by closing doors isn’t limited to the person standing outside them.2
The Competitive Advantage We Are Giving Away
Cem describes America’s ability to attract talent from around the world as one of its great advantages.
For years, he watched gifted students leave Turkey to study in the United States. They stayed, became doctors, engineers, and entrepreneurs, and built lives here. The country didn’t just educate ambitious people. It persuaded them to make America their home.
“It was magnetic for all these brilliant people.”
Then he said something that stopped me.
“We don’t have that anymore.”
It’s an absolute statement, and reality is more complicated. America still attracts exceptional people. But Cem’s worry is clear: make immigration unpredictable, expensive, or frightening enough, and that attraction begins to weaken.
He pointed to the proposed $100,000 payment tied to certain new H-1B hires. As a business owner who had sponsored international employees, he immediately thought about small and midsized companies. A cost like that, he said, could shut them out of competing for talent. 3
The legal outcome matters. So does what the proposal communicates to employers and prospective workers deciding where to invest their futures.
I spent much of my previous career leading engineering teams. I looked for capable people wherever I could find them. I didn’t want the best candidate within a border. I wanted the best person for the work. Cem’s instinct was the same.
And when a country restricts the talent its businesses can recruit, that’s not only an immigration issue. It can become an innovation issue, a competitiveness issue, and ultimately an economic one.
We’ve seen a harsher version of this mistake before. During the Cold War, Chinese-born scientist Qian Xuesen, who had worked at Caltech and helped advance American rocket science, was caught in a security investigation and left the United States in 1955. He went on to become a foundational figure in China’s missile and space programs.4 The circumstances were different, but the lesson is difficult to ignore: expertise turned away does not simply disappear.
Other countries have ambitions, too. Cem knows this. He built a company by recognizing an opportunity before others did. He sees the possibility of America failing to recognize one now.
“I think it is going to bite us back,” he said.
What Happened to the Country He Knew?
The business consequences aren’t the whole of his concern.
Cem remembers arriving in a country where rules felt clear and where he could become part of the society remarkably quickly. He came on a fiancé visa, married Elizabeth, became a permanent resident, and later a citizen. She was a lawyer and handled much of the paperwork. He readily admits that his legal pathway was unusually straightforward.
He was already employing people before he was a citizen. By the time his citizenship arrived, he said, it felt like paperwork catching up with a life he was already living.
He doesn’t claim expertise in the struggles of undocumented immigrants, and he doesn’t argue that America can admit everyone. He understands the argument that laws matter. What he rejects is the idea that rules should erase empathy.
“I just wish that we have more empathy.”
That sentiment isn’t difficult to trace to his own experience. He knows what it means to arrive speaking another language, to be laughed at for an accent, to depend on someone willing to help. At a technical-support job, a customer mocked his pronunciation while others laughed in the background. When Cem ended the call, his supervisor lectured him about how things worked “in America.” He lost the job.
He also knows that his situation today is different. He has money, legal standing, and access to attorneys. His appearance affords him protections he thinks a person with a different skin color might not have. He and Elizabeth raised two children born in the United States to Somali parents. Cem is clear that his children’s experience of racism is not the same as an immigrant’s experience of immigration enforcement. They are Americans, and their experiences of belonging are their own.
For Cem, September 11 marked a turning point. He had grown up around political violence in Turkey, and he recognized how fear could change a society. The United States subsequently expanded surveillance and national-security powers, including through the Patriot Act. Civil-liberties groups documented serious concerns about those changes.5 Cem believes the country’s tolerance and confidence changed with them.
He is nostalgic, and he knows it. Perhaps, he says, he remembers the 1990s through the optimism of youth. That America was not equally open to everyone. Still, the gap between the place he encountered and the one he sees now troubles him.
“I still believe this is the greatest place to live. That’s why I still live here.”
Then, after a pause in the thought:
“However, it’s not the same place.”
He sees a similar change in how other countries look at the United States. Cem now spends much of the year traveling. He remembers how people abroad expressed sympathy after September 11—and how friends in Turkey questioned America’s decision to invade Iraq in 2003. The country that once represented hope to them had become harder to understand. When Cem says America has lost some of its moral standing, he is describing conversations he has had over decades, not a claim that every foreigner sees us the same way.6
Admiration, like entrepreneurial opportunity, cannot simply be assumed to last.
Civilizations Rise. And They Fall.
Near the end of our conversation, Cem’s thoughts turned to Turkey, where he grew up surrounded by reminders that powerful civilizations do not last forever.
He spoke about visiting Troy and Ephesus—places that once stood at the center of great worlds and today remain as ruins. To someone raised with that history, the permanence of any nation or empire is a dangerous assumption.
“As it went up, it can easily go down.”
I don’t hear that as a prediction that America is about to collapse. I hear a warning against complacency.
What struck me was the affection Cem still has for the America he remembers, even as he questions the direction it has taken. He loves this country. He believes in markets, opportunity, hard work, and the freedom to build. But after watching the political and cultural changes of the past three decades, he worries that America is undermining the very qualities that made his success possible.
I keep coming back to that young man sitting on the granite steps in St. Paul. He had an idea, a new marriage, a limited command of English, and a country that seemed to tell him: go ahead, try.
He wasn’t the only young person in the world with intelligence or ambition. He was simply one who got the chance to do something with them.
Think of what followed. Then think of what never gets built when the next person doesn’t get that chance.
That is the America Cem remembers.
And that is what he is afraid we may forget.
—
- By the time of the acquisition, Augusoft’s platform had handled registrations for more than eight million students and processed more than $3 billion in transactions.
Modern Campus, “Modern Campus Acquires Augusoft” (January 19, 2022). ↩ - A peer-reviewed study of U.S. firms found that immigrants play an outsized role in high-growth entrepreneurship, creating businesses and jobs as well as joining the workforce.
Pierre Azoulay, Benjamin F. Jones, J. Daniel Kim, and Javier Miranda, “Immigration and Entrepreneurship in the United States,” American Economic Review: Insights 4, no. 1 (2022).
A separate research review estimated that immigrants account for about a quarter of new American employer businesses.
Saheel A. Chodavadia, Sari Pekkala Kerr, William R. Kerr, and Louis J. Maiden, “Immigrant Entrepreneurship: New Estimates and a Research Agenda,” NBER Working Paper 32400 (2024). ↩ - The requirement was announced and extended, but court decisions blocked its enforcement; it was not being collected as of October 2026.
Federal Register, September 23, 2026, extension of the H-1B proclamation; Yale University Office of International Students & Scholars, immigration updates (last updated October 20, 2026). The proclamation describes a $100,000 payment for certain petitions involving workers outside the U.S.; subsequent court orders blocked implementation as of that update. ↩ - Caltech, “Qian Xuesen (Tsien Hsue-Shen)”. Caltech recounts his surveillance, departure in 1955, and subsequent contributions to China’s missile and space programs; the case is not identical to today’s visa-policy debate. ↩
- American Civil Liberties Union, “Surveillance Under the Patriot Act”. The post-9/11 changes to surveillance and civil liberties are factual history; the conclusion that they fundamentally changed America’s character is Cem’s interpretation. ↩
- There is evidence of that wider unease. In a 2026 Pew Research Center survey covering 36 countries, the median share expressing a favorable view of the United States was 37 percent, while 57 percent viewed it unfavorably.
Pew Research Center, “Trump Gets Negative Reviews Internationally as Fewer Say U.S. Is a Reliable Partner” (June 23, 2026). Median values across 36 surveyed countries; results vary substantially by country and should not be read as the views of every foreign public. See also Pew, “Global Public Opinion in the Bush Years (2001–2008)” on the effects of the Iraq War on America’s global image. ↩